Frequently Asked Questions

Where do you source your cards from?

We source our cards from a variety of places, including box breaks, local card shops and shows, eBay, and trading with other passionate collectors. We’re always on the lookout for unique and rare finds to add to our collection!

 

Are all your cards in mint condition?

We do our best to obtain cards in the best possible condition, but due to the rarity and uniqueness of some cards, it's not always possible to find them all in perfectly mint condition. We carefully inspect each card to ensure it meets our quality standards before making it available to you.

 

Do you edit your card images?

We do not alter our card images in any way except for basic color correction. No blemishes or defects are edited out, so you can see the card exactly as it is. We believe in transparency, and that’s why we provide high-quality imagery to ensure there are no surprises when the card arrives.

 

Do you carry graded cards?

Currently, we don't carry graded cards, but it’s something we’re considering for the future.  To us, the player and the card are what's most important and regardless of condition, we still get the same feeling of excitement and nostalgia.  We understand the appeal of graded cards and may add them to our offerings as we continue to grow.

 

Can I find you at a local card show?

Yes, we plan on selling at local card shows and are excited to meet other passionate Yankees fans in person! We’ll always post our upcoming show appearances on our social media channels, so be sure to follow us for the latest updates. We can’t wait to connect with the community face-to-face!

 

What inspired you to start Pinstripe Exchange?

Our inspiration comes from fellow card collectors and enthusiasts, like Yankee World Series Champion Phil Hughes. His passion for the hobby sparked our own journey into the world of card collecting, and we’re excited to share that passion with you!

 

Are you interested in buying my Yankees cards?


Absolutely! If you have cards you’d like to sell, shoot us an email at support@pinstripe.exchange. We’d be happy to chat with you and see what you have to offer. We’re always on the lookout for exciting additions to our collection!